Article
by Angelo
D'Ascanio |
| |
 |
| |
|
Disclaimer: This article
was written in order to provide information only
and should not be relied upon as legal advice. Detailed legal advice should
be obtained which will be appropriate for the specific circumstances of
your matter. (Copyright and Disclosure).
Should you have any questions relating to
a bankruptcy and/or insolvency matter matters, please contact
Angelo D'Ascanio by e-mail or
by phone at (519) 672-9330. If corresponding by email, be sure to
include your name, your telephone number, and a brief message. |
|
|
Understanding Bankruptcy |
| |
|
Bankruptcy legislation was
originally intended to be primarily a “businessman’s” statute. Its original
purpose was often stated to be twofold:
|
|
|
| 1. |
To permit an honest debtor, who
has been unfortunate in business, to obtain relief from his/her creditors;
and |
| |
|
| 2. |
To provide a regime whereby the creditors of a bankrupt can pursue
their claims by collective action through a Trustee so that the assets
of the bankrupt can be realized and distributed on an equitable basis
subject to the rights of secured creditors and the priorities of
preferred creditors. |
|
|
|
|
In 1992 the Bankruptcy Act was
radically reformed (and renamed the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act) in a
number of ways. One such reform was arguably inconsistent with the original
purpose of the Act, and it ironically has had the most significant impact
on how the Act is used today.
I am talking of course about the
addition of provisions to the Act to make it more easily accessible to
consumer debtors. The statistics are mind boggling. Consumer debtors have
and continue to seek relief from their debts under the Act in record
numbers.
The theory and reality behind what
happens when a consumer debtor declares bankruptcy is as follows:
|
|
|
| 1. |
All unsecured claims against the bankrupt as at the date of bankruptcy are
stayed. This is the immediate relief a consumer debtor obtains, and the
main reason for the bankruptcy; |
| |
|
| 2. |
The trade off is supposed to be
that all of the bankrupt’s property in existence as at the date of
bankruptcy, or acquired thereafter up to the date of the bankrupt’s
discharge, vests in his or her Trustee for distribution among the
bankrupt’s unsecured creditors. However, in the case of property with a
registered lien or mortgage, the Trustee’s interest only attaches to
any equity available in the property, and the Trustee is not entitled to
any property held in trust by the bankrupt for third parties, or any
property exempt from seizure or execution by statute (like the
$5,000.00 exemption for an automobile). In a typical consumer
bankruptcy situation, there aren’t any significant assets for the
Trustee to seize and sell and thus there is usually little or no return
available for the unsecured creditors; |
| |
|
| 3. |
The Trustee has the power to
review the affairs and conduct of the bankrupt with a view to setting
aside any payments made or assets transferred by the bankrupt to third
parties prior to bankruptcy if these payments or transfers constitute a
preference, settlement, or reviewable transaction. However, Trustees
are running a business themselves, and unless there are assets that can
be converted to cash to fund litigation they generally will not spend
their own money to litigate these matters. Under the Act there are
procedures to allow a creditor to take over a Trustee’s right to pursue
such transactions and thus the onus shifts to the individual creditors
to take (and pay for) action; |
| |
|
| 4. |
Individual bankrupts are
required to make monthly “surplus income” payments to their Trustee in
accordance with published guidelines. In a typical consumer bankruptcy
situation, the bankrupt is not a high income earner and has dependents.
The reality is that these surplus payments are usually just enough to
cover the Trustee’s fees and disbursements (with nothing left for the
unsecured creditors); |
| |
|
| 5. |
First time individual bankrupts
are entitled to an absolute discharge from bankruptcy after nine months
unless an objection is filed by a creditor, the Trustee, or the Official
Receiver. First time consumer bankrupts cross their fingers and hope no
one files an objection thereby allowing them to get in and out of the
bankruptcy system after nine months, and with relative ease (except for
those bankrupts who still attach a stigma with going bankrupt); |
| |
|
| 6. |
If a bankrupt is required to
proceed to a discharge hearing, the Registrar will consider the
circumstances and either grant an absolute discharge, or refuse or
suspend the discharge, or order that the bankrupt has to pay a sum of
money to his or her Trustee as a condition of being discharged. An
absolute discharge will be granted if the bankrupt can show the
objections are not valid and that he or she “can not justly be held
responsible” for going bankrupt. Refusals are only ordered in the
rarest of cases where the bankrupt has engaged in really offensive
conduct. The most common disposition at a discharge hearing is for an
order to be made that the bankrupt’s discharge is to take effect after
the bankrupt pays a certain sum of money to his or her Trustee, usually
in monthly instalments of between one to three years. However, the
amount of the monthly payments will depend on the bankrupt’s monthly
household income and expense situation and much reliance is usually
placed on the guidelines referred to above for determining “surplus
income”. Again, unless the bankrupt is a high income earner these
monthly payments may be a lot for the bankrupt but provide little or no
return to the unsecured creditors; |
| |
|
| 7. |
Upon being discharged from
bankruptcy, all claims against the bankrupt in existence as at the date
of bankruptcy, which were stayed, are released and discharged. There
are some exceptions. Most notably these are for family law support
obligations, debts incurred by fraudulent misrepresentation, and
criminal fines or penalties. These claims continue to survive and can
be pursued against the bankrupt. |
|
|
|
|
The reality of a typical consumer
bankruptcy is that the unsecured creditors in most cases receive little, if
any, money on account of their unpaid claims. Many people have criticized
the new bankruptcy system as it applies to consumer debtors as essentially
being “a clearing house” for consumer debt. This may be so, but it should
not diminish the real embarrassment and hardship many consumer bankrupts
experience. Given current economic forecasts, making bankruptcy legislation
more accessible to consumer debtors may be a good or a bad thing, depending
on your perspective.
|
| |
|